ÏÚæÉ ¨¢ÍÖæÑ Ç¨¢ãÄÊãÑ Ç¨¢Óä横 Ǩ¢ãÔÊÑß ¨¢ãÄÓÓÉ Ç¨¢ÏÑÇÓÇÊ Ç¨¢Ý¨¢Óبªä¨ªÉ æãÑßÒ ãϨ¬ Ǩ¢ßÑ㨢
search
 
  Articels
 
حوليات القدس
 
jerusalem quarterly
 
 
 
 
 
Summer 2001,13

Reviews
Full Article PDF          
 
Jerusalem: Caught in Time
Issam Nassar

From 1864 onward, the Palestine Exploration Fund sent a number of photographers to Palestine to accompany the Ordinance Survey of Palestine, Sinai and Transjordan. The work of photographers, such as Sergeants James McDonald and Henry Phillips - and later on, Lieutenant Kitchener - comprised an archive started by the Fund, which expanded, with the addition of a large number of photographs, into one of the largest existing collections of photographs on 19th century Palestine. 

Despite the fact that the Fund's collection constitutes one of the earliest attempts to systematically photograph Palestine, it was not used much by contemporary students of photography until recently; and Colin Osman's Jerusalem: Caught in Time is one of the few books to make extensive use of it. Osman's book includes 153 images of Jerusalem from the 1860s to the early years of the 20th century; all are from the Fund's archive. 

The photographs in the book vary in terms of subject matter and were taken by more than twenty different photographers - the majority of them Europeans. Well reproduced in the book, the photographs cover various sites and themes including: Arab and Jewish life in Jerusalem; Christian and Muslim holy sites; the city walls; and, to some extent, the early signs of modernization. The book also includes photographs by Bonfils, Hornstein, Zangaki, Anon, Raad, Krikorian, Frith, Beato, James Graham, Robertson, Schick, Mason Good, and the American Colony photographers, among others. 

Jerusalem: Caught in Time is divided into eight chapters - each one starting with a short text followed by a number of related images. The logic by which the chapters are divided appears to be thematic. However, whether knowingly or not, the book's division reflects a number of ideas about the city entrenched in 19th century Orientalist discourse, as well as 20th century Zionist discourse. 

The overriding view both advanced by, and reflected in, the organization of the book is that of Jerusalem as a heap of different communities and subjects who have very little in common. By devoting separate chapters to Jewish and Arab life, Osman chooses to frame his visual narrative in the context of the religious/ethnic element on which the claims of the Zionist discourse largely rests. He thereby misses an opportunity to represent the city in terms of - to bring up one of many possibilities - the social lives of its inhabitants. 

The same logic seems to underline the devotion of one chapter to the Holy Sepulcher and the Via Dolorosa and another to the Dome of the Rock. Portraying Jews and Arabs or Muslims and Christians as essentially different and separate communities in 19th century Jerusalem - rather than as Ottoman Jerusalemites who happened to practice different religions and have different holy sites - is misleading and historically inaccurate. It only confirms the mistaken impression that Jews and Arabs were always two different national groups. 

A similar assumption underlies the chapter on Jerusalem's population in which statistics from two Zionist historians, Ben-Arieh and Gilbert, are provided, stating that there were more Jews than Muslims or Christians in Jerusalem in the 19th century. It is peculiar that Osman chooses to give weight only to the statistics of these historians, despite the fact that he seems aware of a discrepancy in sources on Jerusalem's 19th century population (p. 6). Clearly, he gives more weight to numbers based on the guesswork of European consuls in Jerusalem- as in the work of Ben-Arieh-than to the numbers of the official Ottoman census of 1871-2 (p. 6). 

In this regard, Osman's favoring of statistics that give a population margin to Jews over Muslims and Christians is consistent with his reference to 19th century Palestine as Israel: in his discussion of the different photographic processes, he writes that the wet collodion process was "first seen in Israel on Francis Frith's first trip in 1856" (p. 1). 

Although many of the photographs in the book are unknown to the general public, a number of them were published before. The captions and the information provided by Osman with each of the photographs are generally accurate, with a number of minor mistakes. For instance, the pictures of the Khalidiyah Library - transliterated as Haldieh (p. 125), perhaps from the Hebrew - is dated 1900, although the library was in fact established, a year later, in 1901.2 In the photograph by Zangakiof the inside of Jaffa Gate, dated 1900, the section of the wall that the Ottoman authorities demolished in 1898 to open a road to receive Kaiser Wilhelm II of Germany appears to be still intact (p. 41); the opening can be clearly seen in the next picture (p. 42). 

As a book whose focus is essentially on early British photography of the Holy City, Jerusalem: Caught in Time is still a worthy addition to the photographic library. However, its lack of critical scrutiny or of sources for the information provided makes this book problematic. Like many other photography books on Palestine, it shows a lack of knowledge of the history and the issues surrounding the region.

Issam Nassar is the Associate Editor of the JQF

1 A shorter version of this review appeared in the Journal of Palestine Studies, No. 120. 2 "The Khalidiyah Library," Jerusalem Quarterly File no. 3 (Winter 1999): 44-45. 11/12/01


Articles from the same author

Naser-e Khosraw's Journey to Jerusalem ... Autumn 1999, Issue 6

The British School of Archaeology ... Spring 1999, Issue 4

In Their Image ... October 2003, Issue 19

Jerusalem: Caught in Time ... Summer 2001, Issue 13

Photographing the Fourth Army and the Suez Campaign ... Winter 2013/Spring 2014, Issue 56/57

Between Many Jerusalems ... February 2003, Issue 17

Xposure Jerusalem ... November 2002, Issue 16

On Photographs and Returning the Gaze ... Summer 2007, Issue 31

Frame by Frame ... Summer 2007, Issue 31

 

 

 
Copyright for Institute Of Jerusalem Studies

^Top

Privacy Policy

SiteMap

 
The Institute for Palestine Studies
 
Journal of Palestine Studies